The Russian investment company, Renova Group, is controlled by Russian billionaire Viktor Vekselberg, a close ally of President Vladimir Putin who was placed last month on the US Treasury Department’s list of sanctioned individuals and entities for Russian election meddling and other hostile activities.
CNN reported Tuesday that investigators working with special counsel Robert Mueller stopped and questioned Vekselberg at a New York-area airport earlier this year about payments the US investment firm, Columbus Nova, made to Trump’s personal attorney, Michael Cohen. Vekselberg and Columbus Nova founder Andrew Intrater are cousins. Intrater was also questioned by investigators, sources told CNN.
Michael Avenatti, an attorney for porn star Stormy Daniels, alleged Tuesday that Vekselberg made the payments directly, saying, “Mr. Vekselberg and his cousin Mr. Andrew Intrater routed eight payments to Mr. Cohen through a company named Columbus Nova LLC.”
Columbus Nova says Vekselberg’s Russian company is its biggest client, but the company itself is fully owned and operated by US citizens and has never had any foreign ownership. It also says the oligarch had no role in the American firm’s decision to hire Cohen.
But Columbus Nova also has been removing and playing down stronger previous descriptions of its relationship with the Russian firm. The move could be an attempt to mitigate the potential impact on the firm since the US Treasury sanctioned its largest investor, Renova, and Vekselberg earlier this year.
Columbus Nova included the ties to Renova on its site as recently as last spring, but that information has since been removed. An archived copy of the site — available on the Wayback Machine, which catalogues previous versions of websites — links Intrater directly to Renova in his biography.
“Mr. Intrater has, since January 2000, been the Chief Executive Officer of Columbus Nova, the US investment vehicle for the Renova Group which is a multi-national, Zurich-based industrial holding,” his biography said. “He is a former Director and current Member of the Executive Board of Renova Group, a global leader in energy, base metals and mining industries.”
Columbus Nova has used similar language on its website for years.
In filings made with the Securities and Exchange Commission in 2007, Columbus Nova said it was the “US-based affiliate of the Renova Group of companies, one of the largest Russian strategic investors.”
A company spokesman said Columbus Nova’s use of the word affiliate in its SEC filings was never intended to imply ownership. He added that Columbus Nova has removed references to Renova from biographies on its website to clear up media confusion about the relationship between the two companies.
And as recently as November 2017, Renova Group listed Columbus Nova as one “company” out of two dozen that it identified under its “Group” structure, defined as “direct investment fund and portfolio investment funds as well as companies that own and manage industrial and financial assets in various sectors of the economy,” according to an archived copy of Renova’s website.
Intrater formed Columbus Nova in 2000, according to regulatory filings, under the name Renova US Management LLC.
“When Columbus Nova formed a management company under the name Renova US Management, its largest client at the time was a Renova Group company. Throughout its existence, Columbus Nova has managed assets on behalf of Renova Group companies and other clients. Columbus Nova itself is not now, and has never been, owned by any foreign entity or person including Viktor Vekselberg or the Renova Group,” the company said in a statement on its website Wednesday.
“Renova Group is Columbus Nova’s biggest client,” the firm said.
The profile page for Intrater and other executives have been taken down. Columbus Nova has not addressed Intrater’s role as a member of Renova Group’s executive board.
A Columbus Nova spokesman had no immediate comment on Renova identifying Columbus Nova as a “group company.” Renova has not responded to repeated requests for comment.
Renova shut down its webpage in early April, around the time Renova and Vekselberg were placed on the US sanctions list.